Updated
| Torsion | Extension | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it sits | A coil on a shaft above the door | Stretched along each horizontal track |
| Typical doors | Most doors installed in the last 20 years | Older and lighter doors |
| When it breaks | The spring stays on the shaft | Messier; every extension spring should have a safety cable running through it |
| Balance | Easier to balance precisely | Harder to balance evenly (each side works alone) |
How the counterbalance works
A door's weight hangs on a lift cable at each side. On a torsion system the cables wind onto drums at the ends of the spring shaft; on an extension system they run over pulleys. The spring twists (torsion) or stretches (extension) to pay that weight out and take it back. The opener only supplies the nudge. This is why a door with a broken spring defeats its opener: the motor is suddenly asked to deadlift the whole door, and it's not built for that.
Torsion: the modern standard
One or two springs on a shaft above the header. Smoother, safer in failure (the spring stays on the shaft when it breaks), easier to balance precisely, and available in a wide range of cycle ratings. Nearly everything installed in the Triangle since the early 2000s is torsion.
Extension: older and lighter
A spring stretched along each horizontal track, doing its work like a screen-door spring. Cheaper, but harder to balance evenly (each side works alone) and messier in failure, which is why every extension spring should have a safety cable running through it to catch the pieces. If yours doesn't, that's worth a service visit on its own. Many extension doors get converted to torsion at replacement time.
Cycles, not years
Standard springs are rated around 10,000 cycles: one cycle is one open and close. At four cycles a day that's roughly seven years; a busy household using the garage as the front door burns through it faster. That math is where the 7-to-12-year lifespan comes from. High-cycle springs (25,000 and up) cost moderately more and are the right call for heavy-use garages; ask on any spring visit.
What breaking looks like
A loud bang from the garage, then a door the opener strains to lift a few inches. On a two-spring door the survivor has the same mileage as the one that broke, which is why replacing both at once usually beats two service calls a few months apart. Typical prices are in the spring cost guide.
